In Istanbul, hotel quality and hotel location cannot be separated. The city is large enough that a beautiful property in the wrong base can quietly add hours of movement across a four- or five-day stay. OREVYON would choose the neighbourhood first, then the hotel inside it.
Sultanahmet: easiest for the historic core

Choose the historic peninsula when the major monuments are central to your first visit and you want to reach them with minimal morning friction. The advantage is proximity to the headline heritage; the trade-off is that your evenings may feel more tied to a sightseeing district unless you deliberately move elsewhere.
Beyoğlu and Galata: the strongest all-round urban base

This side of the Golden Horn works well when you want restaurants, streets and evening energy to remain part of the trip after the major sights close. It also creates a useful bridge between the historic peninsula, Bosphorus ferries and neighbourhoods farther north. Expect hills and a denser urban feel.
Kadıköy: choose neighbourhood life over monument proximity

Kadıköy is compelling when food, local routine and the experience of crossing the Bosphorus matter as much as immediate access to the classic sights. The ferry becomes part of the daily rhythm. The trade-off is obvious: some headline attractions require a crossing, so this base suits travellers who enjoy movement rather than trying to eliminate it.
One base is usually better than a split stay

For a four- to seven-day city trip, changing hotels often creates more friction than value. A split stay only earns its place if you deliberately want two different versions of Istanbul. Otherwise, keep one strong base and use the transit network to explore.
Pick the evening you want to come home to

The best test is not 'Which area is most central?' but 'Where do I want to be at 21:30 after a full day?' If you want heritage on the doorstep, choose accordingly. If you want dinner and city energy without another transfer, weight Beyoğlu or Galata more heavily. If you want the Asian side to feel like home rather than a day trip, choose Kadıköy.