Where you sleep on Madeira changes the trip: repeated road time, evening choice and which landscapes become easy to revisit.
Funchal · Strongest all-round base

Funchal gives the deepest restaurant and evening choice and makes slower city days useful rather than empty.
Ponta do Sol · Smaller southwest rhythm

Choose it when sunset, atmosphere and westward access matter more than maximum evening choice.
Calheta · Self-drive geometry

Calheta works best when the car is already part of the design and western Madeira will repeat across several days.
Car-free changes the answer

Without a car, Funchal is clearly easier because buses, taxis and organised transfers combine more naturally.
One base or two?

Move only when the second base removes enough repeated driving to earn the packing and check-in friction.
