Milos is strongest when it is treated as a volcanic island with distinct landscapes rather than as a checklist of famous beaches. The geology, fishing villages, local food and access from the sea all matter. For a first trip, decide the base and mobility early, then leave enough weather flexibility for the coast and a boat day.
Four to six nights is the useful first-visit range

Four to six nights gives enough time to see more than the headline coast without turning every day into a beach transfer. A shorter stay can work, but it becomes more vulnerable to wind, changed boat plans or simply spending too much time moving between opposite sides of the island.
Choose your base by evening style and daily movement

Adamas is practical for arrivals, services and central movement. Pollonia creates a smaller seaside rhythm and works well when you want a quieter base. Plaka and Trypiti shift the experience toward hill-village atmosphere and evenings with more character away from the port. The best base is the one that makes the days you expect to repeat easier.
A car or scooter adds real flexibility

Milos is not the kind of island where every interesting coast can be reached equally easily without independent transport. A car or scooter makes it much simpler to combine beaches, villages and viewpoints. Walking still matters within villages, but OREVYON would not build the whole island around a car-free promise unless the itinerary is intentionally narrow.
Keep one day for the island from the water

Official tourism highlights Milos for volcanic formations and coastal landscapes including Sarakiniko and Kleftiko. A boat day is not merely another activity: it reveals parts of the coastline that explain why the island feels geologically different from a conventional Cycladic beach trip. Keep that day flexible enough to respond to conditions.
Do not let the famous beaches erase the rest of Milos

Peak summer can concentrate visitors at the best-known beaches, while nightlife is not the island's main strength. Mix the spectacular coast with village evenings, local products and slower meals. Milos works best when geology and sea create the structure, not when each day is simply another drive to the next photographed cove.