Milos is small enough to feel approachable but dispersed enough that the base still matters. Adamas, Pollonia and Plaka/Trypiti create different daily rhythms. OREVYON would choose the base based on mobility, evening atmosphere and which parts of the island you expect to revisit.
Adamas: strongest for logistics and flexibility

Adamas is the practical choice for arrivals, services and easy movement. It works particularly well for a first visit when you want to keep options open and avoid adding unnecessary friction around transport and boat-day logistics.
Pollonia: a quieter seaside base

Pollonia suits travellers who want a smaller coastal rhythm and slower evenings. It is attractive when the stay should feel relaxed from the moment you return, even if some island exploration requires more deliberate driving.
Plaka and Trypiti: hill-village atmosphere

These bases suit travellers who want village character, elevated views and evenings that feel less tied to the port. They make sense when atmosphere after the beach matters as much as pure transport convenience.
One base is usually enough for four to six nights

Milos rarely needs a split stay on a first trip. With independent transport, one strong base gives enough reach while avoiding hotel-change friction. Split the stay only if you deliberately want two very different island moods.
Choose the base that makes the repeated moments easier

Think beyond the first arrival. Where do you want dinner after a beach day? How quickly do you want to reach the port for a boat excursion? Do you prefer convenience, quiet coast or village atmosphere? The best base answers those questions better than a generic hotel ranking.