Lake Orta is small, but where you sleep still changes the trip. The best base is the place whose evenings and morning movement match what you want from the lake.
Orta San Giulio · Maximum atmosphere

The pedestrian old town, Piazza Motta, island crossings and Sacro Monte sit directly inside your day, with the strongest evening sense of place.
Pettenasco · Quieter lakefront logic

Pettenasco combines lakeside hotels, a promenade and rail access while keeping Orta close enough for deliberate visits.
Omegna · Practical town depth
At the northern end, Omegna adds a larger everyday town, market life, rail access and a different relationship with the lake.
Pella · Opposite-shore quiet

The western shore can suit travellers who value calm and lake views over immediate access to Orta’s evening atmosphere.
One base or two?

For two to four nights, one base is almost always enough. A split stay creates more friction than added depth unless Lake Orta is part of a longer regional trip.