Lake Orta is easy to underestimate because it is small. The best first trip does the opposite: it gives the compact lake enough time to become familiar.
Base the trip around Orta San Giulio

The pedestrian village, Piazza Motta, island and Sacro Monte create the clearest first understanding of the lake.
Cross to Isola San Giulio

The short boat journey changes perspective and introduces the spiritual, quieter side of the destination.
Walk up to Sacro Monte

The twenty chapels and wooded setting add heritage and landscape without requiring a full day away from Orta.
Use the wider lake selectively
Pettenasco, Pella and Omegna are useful contrasts, but they should deepen the stay rather than become boxes to tick.
Stay overnight

Lake Orta earns much of its value before day-trippers arrive and after they leave, when the village and water return to a quieter rhythm.