Menorca is not a simple yes-or-no car destination. The main towns and several visitor areas are accessible without one, but the cost appears when you want spontaneous access to remote coves.
Build around Ciutadella or Maó

Both towns give you food, evenings and transport connections without requiring a vehicle for ordinary city time.
Use buses for the island spine

Public bus connections link the principal population centres and tourist areas, making a town-led itinerary realistic.
Cycling can add range

Menorca’s cycling routes and relatively modest scale can turn short transfers into part of the experience for confident riders.
Remote coves are the friction point

The most secluded beaches do not all fit a simple bus timetable. Access, parking restrictions or seasonal transport can change by location, so verify locally before committing.
Decide what flexibility is worth

Rent a car when the trip depends on choosing coves spontaneously. Skip it when towns, walking, cycling and a smaller number of deliberate coast days sound better.
